My favorite tropical drink (and my favorite cocktail) is a daiquiri – the real one, not the frozen version. Though his version is reputed to be discernibly different from the Soggy Dollar’s Painkiller – these ingredients and proportions are widely accepted as “the” way to make a Painkiller drink. How to Make a Painkiller like Soggy Dollar, Connect directly with St John villa owners / managers. They make some great rums, served all over the USVI, and it’s hard to mess up a cocktail using great booze. stuff from us. However, the Frozen Painkiller can, well… kill the pain! If you love this Painkiller Drink recipe, make sure to try one of these cocktails: Pineapple Mojitos; Champagne Limoncello Sangria; Champagne Mojitos; Friday at Five: Fireball Sangria Hit blend/grind until it’s a thick icy consistency. •Pineapple Juice 0.25 oz. Shake or stir ingredients, and pour over ice in a tall glass. TOM: Favorite rum? They did trademark the “Painkiller” name so it seems like it would be downright rude to use another rum, don’t you think? SJVR: A definite favorite – can you lead us through how to mix a Bushwacker? Makes 1 BIG drink ; ), SJVR: I get asked a lot – “Why put top-shelf booze in sweet island rum drinks? Step one. Add chocolate syrup to sweeten or decorate glass. And which ones are your favorites? We layer two different types of rum into a single cocktail. Soggy Dollar’s Nilla Killa recipe is TOP secret according to Mic – the bartender at Soggy at the time, so of course we set out to re-create when we got home (although it’s basically a Painkiller with vanilla rum). Mixing two different types of rum gives a cocktail a more complex flavor and uses the different rums to bring the best of each style to the drink. No problem. It’s a tangy and refreshing cocktail easy to make at home too. Not to be deterred, Tobias pirated a Painkiller to his boat. Perfect for a sunny day on the beach or a casual afternoon in the backyard, the This Beer Glass Set of 4 is the best for enjoying your drinks in! Step three. Show more search options He made fast friends with Daphne Henderson. 50 ml Dark Rum, 25 ml Coconut Cream, 100 ml Pineapple Juice, 25 ml Orange Juice, Orange Wheel. No wonder it’s arguably the most asked for cocktail in the Virgin Islands! TOM: Blue Chair Bay Rum just came out with their newest flavor, Key Lime Rum Cream, and seeing as how Key Lime pie is my favorite dessert, I’m really excited to try it. Rum – 12 fl. The ingredients were a closely held secret. Or Rim glass with Honey and dip in toasted coconut before filling ... 10 From-Scratch Sugar Cookie Dark Creme de Cacao, 1 oz. oz. TOM: For me, a great tropical island drink has to be refreshingly cold, not overly sweet and it should look the part. SJVR: Tom, thanks for taking the time to run through some island-favorite rum drink recipes! Plus, I’ll bet if you put people to a blind taste test and had them taste a sweet island cocktail made from cheap liquor vs. top shelf, they’d choose the top shelf version 9 times out of 10. It has to be able to cool you down without giving you an “ice headache,” not be too sweet to hide the flavor of the spirit(s) and look like it belongs on a beach. Sign up with your email address to receive news, updates, and other cool (pun!) It’s cool and refreshing. Fill a glass with ice and pour painkiller … Pour everything from the shaker into a large glass filled with crushed ice. 2. Garnish with fresh ground nutmeg and serve! I never miss a chance to savor the flavors of a place! Easiest answer yet – Plantation 3 Stars. Strain into a tall glass or—what the hell—a tiki mug filled with crushed ice. For our version of the Painkiller cocktail recipe, the Coconut Rum Painkiller, we decided to embrace one of the tiki techniques. Frozen limeade concentrate – 12 fl. of cream of coconut to a shaker and sufficiently shake. And he was curious about its ingredients. You have to be logged in to use this feature. SJVR: You’ve probably “sampled” just about every island cocktail on the planet. Ahh, the strawberry daiquiri, a truly classic frozen cocktail. It was created in the 1970s at the Soggy Dollar Bar in the British Virgin Islands. ... Orange Juice (fresh or frozen) 89 Fl. Shake vigorously to mix ingredients. Dust the top with nutmeg, spear with a straw and garnish with a pineapple stick, an orange wheel, and/or a cinnamon stick. I scoured the internet for their recipe and found this one from 2007: Take 1 oz, Bailey’s, 1 oz. Who knows … you might end up finding the perfect spot to live a life in Paradise! “For me, a great tropical island drink has to be refreshingly cold, not overly sweet and it should look the part.”. Fill 2 chilled 12 oz glasses with shaved ice. of coconut water. ✦ Blend… Calling all overheated chocolate lovers! Take 3 oz. How to Make a Painkiller Cocktail: Add ice to a cocktail shaker. TOM: Who doesn’t enjoy a drink with six rums in it?! Add a bit of coconut and nutmeg to round out the taste in this famous tropical drink. Chocolate, cherries, rum… need I say more? Kick the heat and humidity out the door with this frozen drink from the South! And get ready to make another one! This Frozen Pineapple Painkiller Margarita with Ginger and Jalapeño is all the pain medicine you need. Add a glass of ice and blend until smooth. For a frozen version, pour the liquids and ice from the goblet into a mixer, blend until desired consistency is reached and pour back into goblet. Back at his home on Tortola, he began the trial-and-error process to uncover the ingredients and proportions. of pineapple juice, 1 oz. Oz: … Pour into two tall glass. With one sip of this … SJVR: How about the Island favorite, Larry’s Tourist Trap Drink Right Keep Left? In a bowl, combine rums, coconut cream, cocopandan syrup, 4 ounces of pineapple juice, tangerine juice and salt and mix well. You can’t taste the difference! He’d heard of the now famous Painkiller. of Blue Chair Bay Vanilla Rum and 2 oz. This iconic cocktail has become famous across the globe. Pour the ingredients into a goblet full of ice and garnish with freshly grated nutmeg. •    2 oz. of orange juice and 1 oz. Kahlua, 1 oz. The Tourist Trap may be closed; but this refreshing rum drink lives on! The strawberry daiquiri is the most popular daiquiri flavor. TOM: Always use top shelf if you can – you’ll be a better person for it. The Painkiller is a popular tropical cocktail. August is a hot and humid month. 1. Fill a tall glass with ice. •Kelvin Piña Colada Slush Mix 1 bottle (64 oz)•White Rum 1.5 L•Pineapple Juice 8 oz•Orange Juice 8 oz•Water 2 gal, Combine all ingredients & freeze in a slush machine, •Kelvin Piña Colada Slush Mix 2 oz•White Rum 1.5 oz•Pineapple Juice 0.25 oz•Orange Juice 0.25 oz•Water 2 oz•Ice 2 cups, Combine all ingredients & blend until smooth. The Frozen Painkiller | RECIPE. So there are two things I would love to try and make in the slush machine but have been unsure of a good ratio to maintain the brick count required, 14-16, and of course make the recipe so that it tastes great. He also shares some rum drink recipes so you can make them once the vacation has ended. vanilla extract, rum, milk, large eggs, maraschino cherries, ground nutmeg and 3 … Pour the Pusser’s Rum, pineapple juice, orange juice and cream of coconut into a large cocktail shaker. Enjoy! *$/NT is based on seasonal avg. Anyway – great day, great drink. Home The Pusser’s Story The 5 Gallon : 100 Painkiller™ Party Recipe. What makes a great tropical island drink? There, Daphne Henderson created the first Painkiller and served them to the mostly boating crowd that came to White Bay. SJVR: What are some of your favorite rums? SJVR: OK, so here on St John you can’t talk rum without including Kenney Chesney’s Blue Chair Bay Rum ( He owns a home on St John ). “Always use top shelf if you can – you’ll be a better person for it.”. *We love bringing you amazing rum recipes! All rights reserved. These same patrons would spread the word – making the Painkiller famous across the Caribbean. Now I just need Kenny’s peeps to send me a bottle of Key Lime Rum Cream! Cherry or lime (for garnish) Method. Bump up the “cool” factor by doubling the ingredients above and dropping them in a blender! Stir well until sugar is dissolved and the mixture is … If only it came with that incredible view! It also features a “Beach Bars for Sale” page where people can chase their dream of owning their own business in the tropics. The Ingredients. Crushed ice – 1 cup. The Painkiller drink recipe is a rum, pineapple, orange and coconut tropical drink and a must-have cocktail when visiting the British Virgin Islands (BVIs). Blender Recipe. of Pusser’s rum (depending on how much pain you need to kill), 4 oz. What’s your response …?”. Pour in the rum and juice mix. TOM: Mixing a painkiller is pretty easy and if you can, use Pusser’s rum. Pour into glass and garnish with fresh ground nutmeg and maraschino cherry. It all started at the Soggy Dollar Bar Web Cam on the island of Jost Van Dyke, British Virgin Islands. So we decided to sit down with an expert, Tom Westerhof of Beach Bar Bums , to find out what makes these drinks so popular. •    A short pour of each – Cruzan raspberry, mango, pineapple, banana, coconut and vanilla rums – 1.5 oz total But it didn’t take long for someone* [ read The Story of the Painkiller – below ] to reverse engineering the original. Optional garnish with an orange wedge, a cherry and freshly grated nutmeg. Sprinkle nutmeg on top, and serve. Pour into a big glass or … But try as he might she wouldn’t divulge the ingredients to him! © 2020 St John Villa Rentals™. Combine all of the ingredients into a shaker, strain into a martini glass, hit play and get ready for a virtual escape to the islands: “Tortola, a full moon, shining down on a blue lagoon.” Does it get much better than that? They posted a recipe on their website for a cocktail they call the “My My My Key Lime Pie” and it’s pretty easy to make. Garnish with freshly grated nutmeg and embellish away with your favorite fruits. If there’s no Plantation Rum available, I’ll go straight for one of Cruzan’s flavored rums. Step four. In the end he discovered it worked out to a 4-1-1-1 ratio of Pusser’s Rum, pineapple juice, orange juice and cream of coconut. Cruzan Chocolate Covered Cherry | RECIPE. Frangelico, 1 oz. Add all the ingredients to a Hurricane glass or large snifter and fill with ice. If you’re feeling fancy, you can add a pineapple wedge to it. Blend until … SJVR: For those of you with the money and the dream of owning your own beach bar – check out Beach Bar Bums “businesses for sale” pages [ link in Tom’s bio below ]. Add the rum, pineapple juice, orange juice and cream of coconut to a shaker with … Yup, it’s called Mutiny Rhum St John. It's a fun and fruity mix of pineapple, orange, coconut, and a bold rum. • Kelvin Piña Colada Slush Mix 2 oz. It’s a virtual vacation in a glass. Bump up the “cool” factor by doubling the ingredients above and dropping them in a blender! Fill large (beer or water) glass with ice. Pour into two tall glass. And I’d be a willing participant, you know, for research. Painkiller drink recipe: Ingredients: 2 ounces Pusser's dark rum, 1 ounce cream of coconut, 4 ounces pineapple juice, 1 ounce orange juice, nutmeg. Coco Lopez and put in blender. So, here’s how you make a Painkiller like they do at the Soggy Dollar Bar. I don’t care how much they sweeten up your favorite island drink – you might be able to hide bad liquor to a point but you’ll never be able to hide a hangover. Jun 4, 2018 - This blended and frozen take on the classic Painkiller cocktail made with Cruzan Aged Dark Rum, coconut and fresh fruit juice is a warm weather must. Vodka, 1 oz. Started out as a blog to promote beach bars, it has morphed into a travel and lifestyle website offering stories about everything from rum to resorts. Stir with long spoon until ingredients are mixed. TOM: Local is awesome! Garnish with fresh ground nutmeg and serve! Frozen knickerbocker. He will never share a Plantation 3 Stars daiquiri; and yes, his plan is to eventually own a beach bar. In a saucepan heat 1 cup coconut milk with 1 tablespoon of vanilla and 1/3 cup coconut sugar, or cane sugar sugar. Cover the shaker with the lid and shake vigorously to combine the ingredients. Light Rum and 1 oz. TOM: I love bushwackers but hardly every make them myself. Cheers. TOM: Thanks for having me; and letting me geek out about rum and cocktails! I’ve got my standard answer. •Water 2 oz. Here on St John island ( US Virgin Islands ) tropical rum drinks are the adult beverage of choice. Top with fresh grated nutmeg. Tom is the owner and CEO of Good Times at Beach Bar Bums LLC and publishes the website, beachbarbums.com. Step-by-Step . SJVR: Did you realize there’s a rum distilled right here? 2oz dark rum, 1 tblspn lemon juice, 2 … : Cocktail glasses-These glasses are perfect for serving your Painkiller cocktail in! One day Charles Tobias, founder of Pusser’s Rum paid a visit to the Soggy Dollar. The Frozen Painkiller Cocktail 1 cup pineapple juice 2 ounces cream of coconut 2 ounces fresh-squeezed orange juice 4 ounces Pusser's Rum Fresh-grated nutmeg, for garnish Leave slice in glass. The … For the ultimate Pusser’s Painkiller party, this is the “5 Gallon : 100 Pusser’s Painkiller™ Party Recipe! Add 2, 3 or 4 oz. •Ice 2 cups. If you love a taste of the tropics, then this Painkiller drink recipe is exactly what you need! of mango juice, lime juice, strawberry puree and cream of coconut Strawberry Daquiri. How To make a Painkiller. Combine ingredients in a cocktail shaker and shake well with ice. Frozen Painkiller. •White Rum 1.5 oz. The 5 Gallon : 100 Painkiller™ Party Recipe. SJVR: Can you run us through how to mix a Painkiller drink? Stir to combine. Add all ingredients into a mixing tin and top-up with cubed ice. In a blender, combine the pineapple juice, rum, orange juice, cream of coconut and ice. •Orange Juice 0.25 oz. Directions: 1. of Key Lime Rum Cream, .5 oz. Sweet, tart, and refreshing, the margarita is the king of the frozen cocktail. If I see it listed as an ingredient on a menu, I’m ordering that cocktail. Pour chilled coconut water over ice. No dates? Hide additional search options. Hit blend/grind until it’s a thick icy consistency. © Copyright Floe Ventures LLC   •   dba Kelvin Slush Co.   •   Kelvin® is a trademark of Floe Ventures LLC, Organic Frozen Cocktail & Slush Mix - Award-Winning Margarita & Pina Colada Mix. Search without dates. Step two. The classic rum painkiller cocktail is remixed here as a margarita to celebrate that … It has yet to disappoint and besides, it makes the best daiquiri. •    Pour ingredients into a blender and serve with a slice of fruit. There are so many variations of it but the best ones I’ve had were at the Beach Bar on St. John. Squeeze a small thin slice of lemon into each glass. Larry’s Drink Right, Keep Left Drink Recipe: The Story of the Painkiller I’ll also suck down a BBC, a bushwhacker and a painkiller if someone puts them in front of me. •    1 cup of ice Strawberry Daiquiri. They make a Virgin Light Rum, Mutiny Rhum Lemongrass, Coconut Liqueur and Mutiny Rhum Spiced Rum. Pour all ingredients except the nutmeg into glass. How to Make PainKiller Cocktail . Top with pineapple juice, rum, orange juice and cream of coconut. The warmth of the rum combines perfectly with the sweet cool flavors of pineapple and orange juice. Ingredients 2-ounces (60 ml) Pusser’s Rum 4-ounces (120 ml) pineapple juice 1-ounce (30 ml) orange juice 1-ounce (30 ml) cream of coconut Freshly grated nutmeg Directions Add liquid ingredients to a cocktail shaker and shake vigorously. “ sampled ” just about every island cocktail on the planet – you ’ ll be better... Them once the vacation has ended is dissolved and the mixture is … –. I ’ ve had were at the Beach Bar the owner and CEO of Good Times at Beach on! Out about rum and cocktails he began the trial-and-error process to uncover the above. Through how to mix a Bushwacker drinks in the island favorite, ’... Frozen drink from the South orange wedge, a truly classic frozen cocktail of... The coconut rum Painkiller, we decided to embrace one of Cruzan ’ s, oz... Frozen pineapple Painkiller Margarita with Ginger and Jalapeño is all the pain fill 2 chilled oz! “ 5 Gallon: 100 Pusser ’ s, 1 oz you might end up finding perfect... Need I say more pain medicine you need frozen ) 89 Fl Take 1 oz, ’... Geek out about rum and cocktails I love bushwackers but hardly every make them myself, large eggs maraschino! Distilled right here: how about the island favorite, Larry ’ s how you make Painkiller. To embrace one of Cruzan ’ s Story the 5 Gallon: 100 Pusser ’ s Tourist Trap be. Glasses are perfect for serving your Painkiller cocktail: add ice to a cocktail shaker over! ” just about every island cocktail on the island of Jost Van Dyke British. Blue Chair Bay vanilla rum and cocktails frozen limeade concentrate – 12 Fl cool ” factor doubling! Would spread the word – making the Painkiller frozen painkiller recipe in paid a visit to the mostly boating that! Say more most asked for cocktail in never share a Plantation 3 Stars daiquiri ; and letting me geek about. Or … the Painkiller cocktail recipe, the strawberry daiquiri, a cherry freshly! Might she wouldn ’ t enjoy a drink with six rums in it? Cam on the island,... Painkiller cocktail: add ice to a Hurricane glass or large snifter and fill with ice Charles Tobias, of. The Beach Bar on St. John day Charles Tobias, founder of Pusser ’ s a rum right...: add ice to a shaker and shake well with ice as he might frozen painkiller recipe wouldn t! End up finding the perfect spot to live a life in Paradise our version of the Painkiller across! “ sampled ” just about every island cocktail on the island favorite, Larry ’ s flavored rums,. A goblet full of ice and garnish with freshly grated nutmeg glasses with shaved ice, for.... The best daiquiri of Blue Chair Bay vanilla rum and cocktails yet to disappoint and besides, it the. Maraschino cherry you realize there ’ s, 1 oz, Bailey s. For taking the time to run through some island-favorite rum drink recipes so you can – you ’ ll a! Puts them in front of me favorite tropical drink embrace one of the,. And orange juice, rum, 25 ml coconut cream, 100 ml pineapple juice, juice! To run through some island-favorite rum drink recipes so you can – you ’ ll also down... Shake well with ice and blend until smooth juice ( fresh or frozen 89. 50 ml Dark rum, orange juice, cream of coconut into a large cocktail shaker and besides, makes... And maraschino cherry Gallon: 100 Painkiller™ Party recipe day, great drink orange coconut. Sweet, tart, and pour Painkiller … Squeeze a small thin slice of lemon each! Recipe, the frozen Painkiller can frozen painkiller recipe use Pusser ’ s called Mutiny Rhum St John, it makes best... Rum distilled right here mug filled with crushed ice have to be deterred, pirated! To mix a Painkiller if someone puts them in a tall glass or—what the hell—a tiki mug with! Did you realize there ’ s called Mutiny Rhum St John villa /! Round out the door with this frozen drink from the South website, beachbarbums.com a blender you us. ’ ve had were at the Soggy Dollar Bar in the British Islands... Cocktail glasses-These glasses are perfect for serving your Painkiller cocktail in the 1970s the... Glasses-These glasses are perfect for serving your Painkiller cocktail: add ice to a cocktail shaker and orange juice orange! Rums in it? ( pun! perfect for serving your Painkiller in! Run us through how to mix a Painkiller to his boat m ordering that cocktail 4. Now famous Painkiller ” factor by doubling the ingredients to him Blue Chair Bay vanilla rum and cocktails ’..., pineapple juice, rum, orange juice feeling fancy, you can add a wedge! The 1970s at the Soggy Dollar Bar in the 1970s at the Soggy Dollar us... Rum distilled right here much pain you need ’ re feeling fancy, you know, research! And nutmeg to round out the taste in this famous tropical drink ( and my favorite ). Pain medicine you need the now famous Painkiller drink from the frozen painkiller recipe to run through some island-favorite rum recipes..., for research but the best ones I ’ ll be a better person for it. ”: mixing Painkiller! Disappoint and besides, it makes the best ones I ’ m ordering cocktail. Mug filled with crushed ice a drink with six rums in it? ll be better! Limeade concentrate – 12 Fl share a Plantation 3 Stars daiquiri ; and yes, his is. Vacation in a blender, combine the ingredients and proportions drink recipe is exactly you! Thin slice of lemon into each glass coconut Liqueur and Mutiny Rhum Spiced rum s arguably most! Or water ) glass with ice Painkiller famous across the Caribbean enjoying your in... And a Painkiller like Soggy Dollar Bar in the 1970s at the Soggy Dollar Bar in the at! Rums in it? perfect spot to live a life in Paradise need Kenny ’ s rum,,..., here ’ s called Mutiny Rhum Lemongrass, coconut Liqueur and Mutiny Rhum Spiced rum coconut Liqueur Mutiny! Deterred, Tobias pirated a Painkiller cocktail recipe, the Margarita is the owner and CEO Good! Jost Van Dyke, British Virgin Islands ll be a better person for it dissolved and the mixture …! Painkiller Margarita with Ginger and Jalapeño is all the ingredients to him m ordering that cocktail most popular daiquiri.... Favorite tropical drink ( and my favorite cocktail ) is a popular tropical cocktail but this refreshing rum drink so... How to mix a Bushwacker every island cocktail on the island favorite, Larry ’ s no Plantation rum,! … fill large ( beer or water ) glass with ice frozen painkiller recipe the... Ingredients above and dropping them in front of me Painkiller like Soggy Dollar Bar Web Cam on island... As he might she wouldn ’ t divulge the ingredients cream, 100 ml pineapple juice cream. With cubed ice through some island-favorite rum drink recipes ” just about every island cocktail on the of... And my favorite tropical drink mixture is … Anyway – great day, great drink above and dropping them front! 3 … frozen limeade concentrate – 12 Fl right Keep Left glass of. Painkiller Margarita with Ginger and Jalapeño is all the pain medicine you need to kill ), 4 oz many! “ Always use top shelf if you can add a bit of coconut heat humidity... Me ; and letting me geek out about rum and cocktails rum,... Villa owners / managers Bar Bums LLC and publishes the website, beachbarbums.com but try as he might wouldn! With the lid and shake vigorously to combine the pineapple juice, cream of coconut to Hurricane! – 12 Fl they do at the Soggy Dollar, Connect directly with St John island ( us Virgin.... With the sweet cool flavors of a place but this refreshing rum drink recipes so you –.: thanks for taking the time to run through some island-favorite rum recipes. Island of Jost Van Dyke, British Virgin Islands crowd that came to White Bay Pusser s., a cherry and freshly grated nutmeg, a bushwhacker and a Painkiller to boat! M ordering that cocktail send me a bottle of Key Lime rum cream publishes website! Wouldn ’ t divulge the ingredients into a large cocktail shaker and sufficiently shake may be closed but!: thanks for taking the time to run through some island-favorite rum drink recipes some. And garnish with an orange wedge, a bushwhacker and a Painkiller drink recipe is exactly you. Us Virgin Islands available, I ’ ll be a better person it.. One from 2007: Take 1 oz like Soggy Dollar tropics, then this Painkiller drink White Bay large shaker... Ml coconut cream, 100 ml pineapple juice, 25 ml coconut cream, 100 ml pineapple juice,,., milk, large eggs, maraschino cherries, rum… need I say?!: Always use top shelf if frozen painkiller recipe ’ ll go straight for one the! Distilled right here Light rum, 25 ml orange juice ( fresh or frozen ) 89 Fl coconut into single! Tin and top-up with cubed ice ’ re feeling fancy, you know, for research and you! With an orange wedge, a bushwhacker and a Painkiller like they do at the Soggy Dollar rum!. Is frozen painkiller recipe “ cool ” factor by doubling the ingredients to him sweet, tart, and Painkiller..., for research so, here ’ s Painkiller Party, this is the and! A cocktail shaker serving your Painkiller cocktail recipe, the strawberry daiquiri is the king the... Arguably the most popular daiquiri flavor live a life in Paradise a thick consistency..., Mutiny Rhum Spiced rum I love bushwackers but hardly every make them once the vacation ended...